Buy the Smoothy Rock Shoe on http://www.mountaingear.comPrint This PagePrint This Page
Smoothy Rock Shoe image
 
(based on 35 ratings)
Brand:Montrail
Located in:Gear, Climbing, Rock Shoes
Slip into something more comfortable with the Montrail Smoothy, a high-performance synthetic lace-up rock shoe that hugs your foot like a dream. Swathed in a nubuck upper with a cotton canvas liner, your foot will be supported by the molded nylon midsole that provides an excellent edging platform while you grip edges and cracks with the sticky Gryptonite sole.
  • You'll have an unbelievable fit in the nubuck upper that's reinforced with high-frequency welded TPU as it molds to your foot
  • Stay soft and comfy in the cotton-lined canvas upper is lined that eliminates stretching and provides a comfortable, non-greasy surface for your skin
  • Get a strong edging platform with the torsionally rigid midsole is constructed of 1.0 mm molded nylon that's vertically supple enough for great smearing
  • Grip the face with the Gryptonite outsole and toe cap that adhere to the rock with enough cross-linking to allow the rubber to return to its original shape
  • Lock your foot securely in place and support it for maximum control and precision with the heel pocket and unique arch pattern
  • Adjust the integrated speed lacing system that doesn't add bulk
  • Fall 2005 Closeout
  • Upper: micro-perforated synthetic nubuck/HF-welded TPU
    • Lining: cotton canvas
      • Last: slip lasted
        • Outsole: 4 mm Gryptonite
Product Reviews Summary
Avg. Customer Rating:
 
3.3 stars
(based on 35 reviews)
42% of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Customers most agreed on the following attributes:

Pros:
Lightweight(15), Rugged(8)
Best Uses:
Bouldering(16), Casual climbing(10), Climbing gym(14), Indoor(6), Outdoors(3)
Cons:
Flimsy(5), Uncomfortable(13)
Describe Yourself:
Avid climber(4), Casual/ recreational(4), Getting started(3)
 
Nop bad for the price
By DarkagelinkVerified Purchaser from New York, NY on 8/24/2008
Sizing:
Feels half size too small
Width:
Feels too narrow
Pros:
Rugged, Weather Resistant
Cons:
Uncomfortable
Best Uses:
Bouldering
Describe Yourself:
Getting Started
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend

well just keep in mind that you pay for what u get :O).

 
Smoothy
By LTVerified Purchaser from TX on 3/11/2008
Sizing:
Feels half size too small
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Lightweight
Cons:
Uncomfortable
Best Uses:
Indoor
Describe Yourself:
Casual/ Recreational
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

I use this shoe on an indoor wall only, and it has worked really well for me so far. I'm still breaking them in, but have climbed many days in a row with them without any problem! They are a little tight, order at least a whole size up from your regular shoe (even if you want your climbing shoes to be tight).

 
Could be better
By Average gym climberVerified Reviewer from St. Louis, MO on 3/6/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Sticky
Cons:
Uncomfortable
Best Uses:
Indoor
Describe Yourself:
Casual/ Recreational
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The tongue of the shoe really digs into my leg. I don't know why the tongue of a shoe needs to be stiff. The rubber is soft and sticky but that means it'll wear out a lot quicker than hard rubber. It's a pretty good and cheap shoe for the technical climber but durability is questionable.

 
Great shoe for the price
By RegiomentanoVerified Reviewer from Monterrey, Mexico on 3/4/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Good value
Cons:
None
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Indoor, Long Climbs, Outdoor
Describe Yourself:
Avid Climber
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

I have bought two pairs, and the only complain I have is that since day one looks like the sole tends to separate from the toe area, it does only a couple of milimeters, and stays that way, first I was afraid about durability but that lasted as long as any good shoe, funcionality wasn't affected.

 
Extremely good quality for the price
By Loz the hopeful spiderwomanVerified Purchaser from Norman, OK on 2/15/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Lightweight
Cons:
Uncomfortable
Best Uses:
Indoor
Describe Yourself:
Getting Started
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

They are very uncomfortable at first and are not shoes you would want to wak around in, but they definitely do make a difference in climbing. And based on other reviews I got the size slightly smaller, as I was told that they do stretch after a while.

 
Good Rock Shoes
By TreemonkVerified Purchaser from Reinholds, PA on 12/9/2007
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Awesome edging power, Fits perfectly, Similar fit as Muira, Stiff sole, Well fitted in the toe, Well fitting in the heel
Cons:
Slow breaking in
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Indoor, Outdoor, Sprint Climbs
Describe Yourself:
Avid Climber
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

I climb alot of sport, and indoor. Some trad, though not my choice of trad climbing shoe. The sole is super stiff. Excels on small edges. The heel rand is very snug, so no heel slip. The fit is similar to my Muira's from La Sportiva. The sytnthetic material is slow to break in.
A long story short, I have no regrets about this purchase, and enjoy climbing in my Montrail, Smoothies.

 
decent shoe - bad rubber
By MarcoPolo from New England on 12/6/2007
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Cheap - closeout
Cons:
Bad rubber, Flimsy
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Indoor, Outdoor
Describe Yourself:
Casual/ Recreational
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend

bought these shoes because they were a closeout and were inexpensive. The shoes are not to bad, a little stiff overall. BIGGEST CON is the fact that the rubber is too soft and is horrible for edging and smearing.
If your looking for an inexpensive shoe for the beginner, this isn't a bad shoe ... but don't expect to get a ton of use or performance out if it.

 
Not so good
By Go greenVerified Purchaser from Redmond, WA on 10/18/2007
Sizing:
Feels full size too small
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Cheap
Cons:
Uncomfortable
Describe Yourself:
Casual/ Recreational
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I tried to be cheap but it didn't work out. The shoes were smaller than I thought. It is similar to other climbing shoes though. The size didn't fit and the shoes surface material is too hard for my arch.

 
Good for a beginner
By BrianVerified Purchaser from Washington, DC on 8/14/2007
Sizing:
Feels half size too small
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Lightweight
Cons:
Flimsy
Describe Yourself:
Avid Climber
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

I got them for a friend of mine that was just starting out climbing. They were a great shoe for the price. She has been out a couple times and they are doing just fine but if she decides to move to bigger routes or lead climbing she will want to get another pair.

 
Completely de-laminating in 10 days..
By Teton Climber from Jackson Hole, WY on 5/16/2007
Comfort:
Breathes Well
Sizing:
Feels half size too small
Width:
Feels true to width
Cons:
Flimsy, No Durablility
Best Uses:
Sport climbing
Describe Yourself:
Competitive Climber
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend

These shoes fit well, and climb well on edgy faces and sport sports. Too bad they are completely de-laminating, and the rubber is basically disintegrating around the entire toe area after less than 10 days of outdoor use.I do not recommend these shoes to anyone, they rate a zero on the durability scale. Definitely not worth [$].

 
bad construction all around
By LJVerified Reviewer from chicago IL on 3/13/2007
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Width:
Feels true to width
Cons:
Flimsy, Poor construction, Uncomfortable
Describe Yourself:
Avid Climber
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Terrible! This was my first pair of montrails and I am deterred to buy their brand ever again... This rubber although sticky had weird bubbly holes in it after the first week! of regular climb. Their is a gap that was visiable when I got them and the sole of the shoe has been slowly ripping away on both shoes. After about one month the upper started to pull away from the toe area showing the glue and it has gotten uncomfortable on toe hooks. The color is pretty but the shoe sucks and is falling apart after only 3 months of indoor gym climbing. Save your [...]$!!!

[0 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Uncomfortable!
By chVerified Purchaser from Michigan on 2/20/2007
Comfort:
Heel cup very stiff, Painfully tight
Sizing:
Feels full size too small
Width:
Feels too narrow
Pros:
Nice color
Cons:
Uncomfortable
Describe Yourself:
Getting Started
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Despite ordering larger size than needed, they were too tight and stiff to even break in. Two of us ordered them and need to return them.

[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Extremely small but perfect
By XmitsosVerified Purchaser from Greece on 12/22/2006
Comfort:
Breathes Well
Sizing:
Feels half size too small
Width:
Feels true to width
Pros:
Rugged
Cons:
Flimsy
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Casual Climbing, Trad Climbing

At the start,it was really small.My foot could not even get in the shoe.But,after i wore and use it on the rocks,and the shoe took my foot format,it became just perfect!thank you!

 
Montrail Smoothy
By Shaggy from Atlanta, GA on 12/12/2006
Pros:
Lightweight
Cons:
Uncomfortable
Best Uses:
Climbing Gym

This shoe is very uncomfortable and doesn't last very long. The toe blew out the first time i used them in the gym. i don't recomend these shoes for anyone.

Mountain Gear Response: Satisfaction Guaranteed On Every Purchase
We guarantee every product we sell. If one of our products does not meet your expectations during its useful life, we promise to repair it, replace it or give you a refund.

Items may be returned for a full product refund if new and in original packaging. We suggest you ship your return package via UPS and insure it. All return costs are the purchaser's responsibility. Mountain Gear will pay for ground shipping fees on outbound exchanges.

If you ever have a question on anything you bought from us, please let us know. If you?re not happy, we?re not happy.

[0 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Ugh, terrible!
By Zeffe from Baltimore, MD on 12/9/2006
Best Uses:
Climbing Gym

Ouch, these things HURT and I bought the same size as any other climbing shoe. I got them purely for off-season gym use but after wearing Mythos for a while these seemed made of metal. Despite the nice price I would spend a little more and get something usable. Returned immediately [...].

Mountain Gear Response: Satisfaction Guaranteed On Every Purchase
We guarantee every product we sell. If one of our products does not meet your expectations during its useful life, we promise to repair it, replace it or give you a refund.

Items may be returned for a full product refund if new and in original packaging. We suggest you ship your return package via UPS and insure it. All return costs are the purchaser's responsibility. Mountain Gear will pay for ground shipping fees on outbound exchanges.

If you ever have a question on anything you bought from us, please let us know. If you?re not happy, we?re not happy.

[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Nice Arc and Comfortable
By Matty P. from Tuscaloosa, AL on 11/28/2006
Pros:
Lightweight, Weather Resistant
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Climbing Gym

I have a narrow foot, and this shoe came out well for me, the fit is perfect for me. I like the arch, not too extreme and not too little.

 
Painfully small
By RoadTripperVerified Purchaser from Central Illinois on 11/28/2006
Pros:
Rugged
Cons:
Uncomfortable
Best Uses:
Climbing Gym

Maybe my pain threshhold isn't high enough, but these are too painful even to break in. I ordered them the same size as nearly every other climbing shoe I've ever owned (I've had one paid in a smaller size) and my toes were extremely painful. The tongue also was uncomfortable. On the positive side, they edged well and the pointy toes fit in small pockets.

[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Great intro...Crapy longevity
By McTechi from Santa Barbara, Ca on 11/26/2006
Pros:
Bang for buck
Cons:
Get what you pay for
Best Uses:
Bouldering

Thought this was a great shoe. i didn't have any problems with the sizing (euro shoe size), could have been 0.5 smaller.

I have had them for about 1.5 months and already the bottoms are well worn off, they have very little edge left esspecialy on the toe. I wouldn't recomment these for bouldering or any sport climbing; top roping they are great, but thats about it.

[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
These shoes are great!
By M[..]Verified Purchaser from Ohio on 11/15/2006

These shoes are great! The fit is a lil snug, so If you like a relaxed fit order a half size larger. Other then that great deal and great shoe!

[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Great shoe
By Dbrew from Warrensburg, mo on 11/5/2006
Pros:
Lightweight, Molds to your feet, Rugged, Sticky rubber
Cons:
Not an all day shoe
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Climbing Gym

Great shoe, fits about a size smaller than street shoes. Molds to feet, especially if heat fitted. Great shoe for gym climbing, need to be removed between climbs for comfort. Great shoe for the money.

[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Shoes are small
By MorganVerified Purchaser from Richmond, VA on 10/17/2006
Cons:
Uncomfortable

The Smoothy shoes run small so when you order at least order a half size to big. I know climbing shoes aren't comfortable but when they don't fit they are even more uncomfortable. The Smoothy shoes also ride very high on the back of you ankle. When climbing it doesn't bug you as much but when your standing around the digging into the back of the ankle is really annoying.

[0 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Good Shoe
By StasVerified Purchaser from Seattle, WA on 10/2/2006
Pros:
Lightweight, Rugged
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Casual Climbing, Climbing Gym

My first shoe and it works great.

 
Comfortable, a great climbing shoe
By AlbalVerified Purchaser from Atlanta, GA on 9/21/2006
Pros:
Lightweight
Best Uses:
Climbing Gym

Great for indoor rock climbing

[0 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Great fit and feel on the the rock.
By Mountain BulldogVerified Purchaser from Starkville, MS on 9/20/2006
Pros:
Lightweight, Versatile
Best Uses:
Casual Climbing

I'm quite happy with my first shoes to own... [...]

[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
maybe it's just me...
By tallboy27Verified Reviewer from nashville, tn on 9/8/2006
Pros:
Lightweight
Cons:
Overly tight, Uncomfortable

i'll admit up front that i bought these shoes 1/2 size smaller than normal thinking that, even if they didn't stretch, they'd at least get a little bit flexible and i'd wind up with a sweet non-leather shoe for cheap.

after a couple of weeks climbing in them they haven't given up any of the rigidity (is that a word) in the heel and i'm beginning to think these will be great gym shoes (read: on for 30 minutes, off for 15 minutes) but not something i'd wear for much longer than that.

lesson learned: overly tight shoes, even on clearance pricing, still suck.

 
good shoes for the price!
By ZachVerified Purchaser from Rapid City, SD on 8/28/2006
Pros:
Versatile
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Casual Climbing, Climbing Gym

A great rock shoe! I actually own two pairs of smoothys. This is a fairly technical shoe that is versatile. They edge and smear well. The gryptonite rubber is very good. I have a wider foot and they fit me really well, having a similar fit to a five-ten rock shoe. I really like the quick lacing. Almost as fast to get on and off as a Velcro shoe. The heel is great for heel hooking. The shoes are made out of a kind of a thicker plastic. This takes a while to get use to. In addition, I wish the shoes were a little more sensitive but probably make great crack climbing shoes.

 
Good shoe as an intermediate climber
By frankthetankVerified Purchaser from Manhattan, kansas on 8/22/2006
Pros:
Lightweight, Rugged
Cons:
HOT
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Casual Climbing, Climbing Gym, delicate sport climbs

I like this shoe by montrail, and it did great on my last climbing trip. I am an intermediate climber, and this shoe was great for the 5-9 and 5-10 sport routes I need it for. It clings well to small holds and wedges in cracks well. The major downside is this: when this shoe is in direct sunlight, the rubber of the toes gets almost unbearably hot. My feet were burning so bad that I had to repeatedly take them off as I was repelling down from climbs, just to get some relief. So, if you're in a part of the country with a lot of hear, I'd say shy away from this shoe. My La Sportivas did fine in the sunlight when I switched over to them

Otherwise a good rock shoe.

 
Good value for money
By hawkpatriotVerified Purchaser from Bellaire, TX on 8/16/2006
Pros:
Lightweight, They are fairly rugged
Cons:
Not sure about its life
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Casual Climbing, Climbing Gym

I would say it is a good product for its price, kind of a value for money. This is my first purchase so I am not in a position to comment a lot.
They fit well overall especially in the instep. The sole is sturdy and the toes are strong enough for foot jams. I have done upto 5.10 climbs indoors and outdoors and they work well for me. I do not see any reason why they will not work for bouldering though I haven't done one in them.
On the negative, I am not sure if they are robust enough to take a lot if you do climbing on a more regular basis. (The lace has started to crack in 2 weeks)
Overall a 4 out of 5.

 
very nice shoe for the money!
By neoVerified Purchaser from Silver Creek, Ga. on 8/13/2006
Pros:
Durable, Lightweight, Rugged
Cons:
Just a little narrow, Uncomfortable
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Casual Climbing, Climbing Gym

These shoes grip like no other. They are about the stickest shoe ive worn.

 
" If the shoe fits, wear it! "
By jacqVerified Purchaser from Chicago, IL on 8/3/2006
Pros:
Comfortable, all day, Sticky rubber, Technical
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Casual Climbing, Climbing Gym, Sport

Great shoe for a great price. I like the way Montrail fits my foot; snug but not uncomfortable. You can climb in these all day with little or no pain. I wear a 8.5 in street shoes, and i only went 1/2 size down in the Smoothy. The rubber seems like it will strech slightly. I've only tested these out in the gym so far, but i can tell that they would do well outdoors with edging and more technical climbs. The Gryptonite rubber is sticky but not as much as other brands. All around these are a good shoe and you cant beat the price!

 
Good shoe for [...]
By Troy916Verified Reviewer from Columbia, MD on 7/26/2006
Pros:
Decent rubber, Laces

I haven't bouldered in them yet but they have kept my footing on 5.11 I also like that the sole is somewhat stiff, not flimsy.

 
Great Shoe
By BorisVerified Purchaser from Oregon on 7/19/2006
Pros:
Fits perfectly, Lightweight, Rugged
Best Uses:
Casual Climbing, Face

For the price this was a great shoe. Works great with the type of clibing I do. Mostly face climbing some cracks.

 
Nice But TITE!
By dr. phil mountain manVerified Purchaser from Cedarville OHIO on 7/17/2006
Pros:
Lightweight
Cons:
Uncomfortable
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Casual Climbing, Climbing Gym

These shoes are ok. not the greatest fit but everyshoe is made for a different person.

 
Surprisingly Performy Simplicity
By Green UpVerified Purchaser from Bloomington, IN on 7/13/2006
Pros:
Performance Fit, Simple Lacing, Solid Edge
Cons:
Breathability
Best Uses:
Bouldering, Climbing Gym

Haven't used them much yet; but the Smoothy fits like a perfomance shoe, but slides on and off easily thanks to unique lacing style.

[2 of 2 customers found this review helpful]

 
Slab Slayer
By DanVerified Purchaser from Colorado Springs, CO on 6/26/2006
Pros:
Great edging shoe
Cons:
The shoe does get hot
Best Uses:
Edging on Slab

Great edging shoe, this is the second pair that I have purchased I live in Colorado and climb quite a bit of slab, very thin edges and this shoe has greatly out performed all the others I have tried on slab. I use other shoes for gym climbing and the like but when it comes to thin edges it is truly amazing... The only draw back is that the shoe does get quite hot on warm days, but that is what tevas are for.

Customer Reviews about the Smoothy Rock Shoe at Mountain Gear
Powered by PowerReviews
Copyright © 2008 Mountain Gear All Rights Reserved. Do not republish contents.